We should warn you: If you’ve ever read a Nokia or Windows Phone review before (like the Lumia 928),
you might feel a sense of déjà vu reading this review. Though it’s
packing a powerful new camera and a fancy four-digit number, everything
else about the Lumia 1020 could be applied to the Lumia 920, Lumia 925, Lumia 928, and most every other Windows Phone 8 device. There is good and bad in every Windows Phone, as Nokia has learned since it hitched its smartphone dreams to Microsoft’s wagon in 2011.
Comfortable, once you get used to hump
Along with the Samsung Galaxy S4 Zoom, Nokia’s new Lumia is
attempting to take smartphone cameras to the next level. But no great
leap comes without its consequences, and for the 1020, that consequence
is a big round camera bump on the back. At 10.4mm, it’s still thin, but
there’s no avoiding the feeling that a camera lens is pressing against
your palm as you hold it.
The camera was noticeable and annoying at first – incredibly thin
phones like the HTC One spoil us – but after a few hours, we got used to
the feel. And after using the camera, we forgave it for having a big
booty.
Aside from its big round metal ass, the Lumia 1020 looks and feels fantastic.
Aside from its big round metal ass, the Lumia 1020 looks and feels
fantastic. It resembles most every other Lumia. It has a solid, unibody
shell made of polycarbonate (color choices: black, white, yellow) with
sharp corners, but curved sides. We’re not sure if we’re just getting
very used to Nokia’s designs, but the 1020 felt easy to hold and use.
The Power and Volume buttons are smartly placed on the right side,
allowing you to press Power and hit the navigation buttons – Back,
Start, Search – without shimmying the phone up and down your hand, a
common problem with big-screened smartphones. Every time you don’t have
to shift the phone in your hand is one less opportunity to drop it. We
give props to Nokia for recognizing the need for intuitive button
placement.
Gorgeous screen and decent sound
We don’t always add a section in a review for screen quality and
sound, but Nokia outperforms many competitors in these areas. Like most
of its Windows Phones, the Lumia 1020 has an AMOLED screen with some
extra enhancements to further emphasize deep blacks and smooth motion
(the Nokia team calls it PureMotion+). The technical details are
unimportant. What is striking is how bright and vivid the 1020’s display
is when you see the Windows Phone Start screen. It’s gorgeous and the
background is so black that it blends in seamlessly with the black glass
edging, which itself curves over the edge of the phone just a little.
You don’t have to be a screen buff to notice how the colors pop.
The Lumia 1020 doesn’t have the sound chops of an HTC One or iPhone
5, but it does reach a decent volume for a smartphone. Sound tends to
have less depth than Apple’s phone, but if you need to play a tune for
friends, the Lumia will be audible.
WP8 still has drawbacks, but Nokia’s apps are nice
Windows Phone 8, like Windows 8, is a polarizing operating system. It’s different from Android
and iOS, which means it comes with a learning curve. Fans of things
like notifications will have an especially difficult transition, because
WP8 just doesn’t manage them well, yet. However, having a screen of
Live Tiles – which are a mix between a widget that displays information
and an icon – does have benefits. WP8’s Start screen has a lot of
customization options once you start digging in. You can also Pin almost
anything to the Start screen. For example, instead of just pinning the
Spotify app, you could pin your favorite playlist.
One of the continuing downsides to Microsoft’s OS are apps. There are
some holes in the Windows Phone Store. However, to Nokia’s credit, it
has attempted to fill some of those holes. Nokia’s Here Maps, Transit
app, Weather Channel app, ESPN app, and CNN app fill in where
Microsoft’s app collection fails. Nokia’s new camera apps are also
pretty good, but we’ll get into them later.
AT&T has installed five of its own apps, but thankfully, you can
delete them all, if you wish. Unless you want to use an AT&T
Navigation app instead of Nokia’s, we recommend you do.
This camera puts all others to shame
I am not a photo buff. When I use a smartphone camera, I want it to
just work. Most of you are probably the same. That’s why we most heavily
weigh the default auto modes of phone cameras higher than anything
else. It’s nice to have extra settings, but you shouldn’t have to use
them very often. When you whip out your phone to take a shot, you may
not have time to fiddle around, either. Luckily, Auto mode is where the
Lumia 1020’s 41-megapixel PureView camera shines.
Based on the 41-megapixel camera in the old PureView 808, the 1020 is a hearty step above any other smartphone camera (though we aren’t sure how it stacks up to the GS4 Zoom). Most smartphone cameras top out around 13 megapixels these days, but Nokia heartily tops that.
Here’s how it works: You can get a 34- or 38-megapixel version of any
shot, but for the sake of sharing, Nokia crunches all the megapixels
down and gives you a 5-megapixel version to share and use, which is
plenty big for most of us.
But it’s not all about the megapixels. Nokia has significantly
increased the sensor size of the camera as well, the Xenon flash is
powerful, and a mechanical shutter is in place.
In a shoot off with the iPhone 5, the 1020’s camera outperformed it in low-light areas and produced more vivid photographs.
As DT’s photography editor Les Shu pointed out
at the Lumia 1020 launch event, this may be the first smartphone camera
to outperform cheaper point-and-shoot cameras. After taking a bunch of
pictures, we think this might indeed be the case.
In a shoot off with the iPhone 5, the 1020’s camera outperformed it
significantly in low-light areas and produced clearer and more vivid
photographs.
A big difference between the two may come down to a matter of choice.
Nokia’s onboard photo filters automatically amp up the brightness and
color contrast of objects, sometimes making them appear to almost glow.
Apple’s camera shows things more as they are, which means more accurate,
but more drab shots. There is a time and place for both styles, but
we’ve grown to prefer Nokia’s more beautiful take on the world. The
Lumia 1020 also balances bright lights and dark areas far better than
the iPhone 5 and other smartphone cameras. So if you have a window in
the shot, the rest of your wall won’t look completely black, or your
window won’t look like it’s a gate to heaven.
The extra settings in Nokia’s custom Pro Cam app allow you to adjust
shutter speed, white balance, ISO, aperture, etc, but don’t require it. A
separate “Smart Cam” app (poorly named) lets you take a bunch of
pictures at once, like a flipbook, and piece them together in cool ways.
Overall, we are very impressed with Nokia’s PureView. It is the best smartphone camera available today.
Standard specs, great talk quality, unimpressive battery
This section mirrors what we said about the Lumia 928 because, well,
this is essentially the same phone, on the inside, with double the RAM.
The Lumia 1020 runs on great – though not industry leading – hardware.
It has a 1.5GHz dual-core Qualcomm Snapdragon S4 processor (same as the Galaxy S3 and HTC One X),
2GB of RAM, 32GB of internal memory to store your many pictures, an
amazing rear camera, and a 4.5-inch 1280 x 768 pixel AMOLED screen.
Benchmarks: Though we can’t run a Quadrant test on
the Lumia 1020 like we can on Android phones, we would guess it would
get around 4,000 to 5,000. That number likely means nothing to you, but
it means it’s about on par with high-end phones of mid-2012. But even
that means little. Let’s put it like this: The 1020 runs apps smoothly
and we haven’t encountered any slowdown, except when using the camera
app every so often. Windows Phone still has more load screens, slower
animations, and seems less responsive than newer Android phones and the
iPhone, but the Lumia runs WP8 as fast as any device could.
Talk and Data: AT&T hasn’t yet upgraded to HD
Voice, so talk quality is still fairly low. But we haven’t had any
troubles hearing or being heard, and quality exceeded the Galaxy S4 Active
we recently reviewed (ever so slightly). AT&T’s LTE network has
been speedy with download rates around 6Mbps and 1.6Mbps on the upload,
which is on par with other devices in our current testing area of rural
Michigan.
Battery: Nokia has packed a 2,000mAh battery in the
928, which isn’t as massive as the 3,000mAh batteries in the Droid Maxx
and some larger phones like the Galaxy Note 2, but seems to be big
enough to let the Lumia mostly make it through a day. Unfortunately, the
battery is not removable, so if you run out of juice, you’ll need to
charge up. Nokia claims that the battery will last 6.8 hours if you’re
continuously watching videos and 5.5 hours if you’re browsing the Web on
Wi-Fi. This is about in line with what we’ve gotten. Using the camera
heavily, we’re at about a 40 percent charge in just a few hours, but on
an ordinary day, we’d expect it to last longer. If you’re in dire
trouble, there’s a battery saving mode, which can give you an extra hour
or two of life.
Conclusion
The Lumia 1020 lives and dies by its camera, and that camera is as
amazing as Nokia claims. If you value high-quality shots above all else
and you’re on AT&T, we recommend you pick it up. There are a few
downsides. The battery life isn’t great, you will have to put up with
areas where Windows Phone lacks, and that bump on the back isn’t going
away. This will never be a supremely comfortable phone to hold. Oh, and
the price is high. This will set you back $300 with a two-year contract
and $660 without. That’s a high premium, especially when you can get the
Galaxy S4 Active – which is more powerful, waterproof, and also has a
decent camera – for $200, or $595 without a contract. And there’s always
the iPhone 5, which is never a bad decision.
There’s really one question you need to ask yourself: Do you feel
lucky? Because with any other camera, you’re going to need a little luck
to end up with a good shot. Nokia’s PureView ups your odds.
Highs
- Best smartphone camera available
- Gorgeous AMOLED screen
- Great exclusive apps
- Good sound volume
- Clear call quality
Lows
- Windows Phone 8 lacks certain apps
- Windows Phone 8 still has some quirksa
- No microSD card support
- Battery is not removable
- Expensive $300 price tag
